21 Paper Bag Halloween Crafts That End Up as Puppets and Treat Holders

Kraft paper bags are the most underrated supply in the Halloween cupboard. They are cheap, flat-pack, sturdy enough to hold candy and take paint, card, crepe paper and ribbon without buckling.

The crafts here cover the whole October calendar: class party favours, trick-or-treat bags a child will actually want to carry, table centrepieces that come together in under an hour, and hand puppets that keep kids busy for the whole party.

Every craft below lists exactly what you need and walks through the method in order.

Active time is always separated from drying time, because the wait is sometimes the longest part, and that matters when you are making twenty of something the night before a party.

A few of these suit children working alongside an adult; where cutting or hot glue is involved, the step says so. Difficulty ratings are honest.

This post contains affiliate links. If you buy through them, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

One-Eyed Monster Treat Bags

These are the bags that stop a kid mid-stride. A single enormous eye stares out from the folded flap, and a jagged row of white teeth lines the opening so the bag looks like it is mid-bite.

Finished bags stand upright on a table or hang in a row from a washing line strung across the party room. After the party, flatten them and slide them back into the original bag stack for next year.

Witch-Legs Favour Bag

This one leans into the classic Halloween image of a witch stuck headfirst in a cauldron, legs waving in the air.

Striped orange-and-black legs with curly-toed boots are glued to the front of a kraft bag, and a ruffle of black crepe paper runs across the middle like a skirt hem. The result is theatrical for a classroom party or a neighbour treat drop.

Store flat with the crepe ruffle tucked inside.

Witch Broom Treat Bag

The top of the bag gets fringed and fanned upward so it becomes the bristle end of a broom, and a wooden dowel poked through the gathered waist becomes the handle. Tied with Halloween ribbon, the whole thing reads as a tiny flying broom.

A dozen of these clustered in a jug on the party table look like a prop from a witches’ supply shop. Pull the dowels out after the party and the bags collapse flat for storage.

Hand-Painted Personalised Trick-or-Treat Bag

A kraft gift bag with handles becomes a proper trick-or-treat bag when you paint a ghost, pumpkin or spider-web scene on the front and write the child’s name in bold letters.

Acrylic paint on kraft paper dries opaque and stays put through a full night of candy collection. The bag is sturdy enough to be reused for years. Store it flat inside a larger bag at the end of the season.

Paper Bag Frankenstein Puppet

A flat-bottomed paper bag makes an ideal hand puppet: the fold at the base becomes the jaw, and fingers slide into the flap to work the mouth. Frankenstein’s green face, bolts and stitched forehead translate perfectly to the boxy shape of a small bag.

This is the craft that keeps a party table occupied for a solid forty minutes, and the puppets end up as the afternoon’s entertainment. Store them flat in a stack.

Mummy Treat Bag

White crepe paper bandages wind around a standard lunch bag in overlapping strips, leaving two googly eyes peering out from the gaps.

It is quick enough to make in a batch of twenty, and the slightly irregular wrapping is part of the look rather than a flaw. Line a row of these along a windowsill or use them as individual favour bags at each place setting.

The crepe peels off easily afterward if you want to reuse the bags.

Black Cat Paper Bag Puppet

The bag’s flat bottom becomes the cat’s forehead, and a pair of pointed card ears glued to the corners give the whole shape immediately.

Pipe cleaner whiskers, a pink felt nose and narrowed yellow eyes finish a face that is genuinely cute rather than scary, which suits younger party guests perfectly.

Keep these for a Halloween craft station: children decorate their own, then perform a five-minute puppet show before the cake comes out.

Spider Web Tissue-Paper Luminaria

A paper lunch bag becomes a glowing lantern when a white tissue paper web is glued inside and a battery tea light dropped into the base.

The light shines through the tissue and the kraft paper turns warm amber around it, which looks genuinely good lined up along a path or mantelpiece. This is a stationary craft: never use real candles inside paper bags.

Battery tea lights are the safe and easy answer, and they last all evening on one set of batteries.

Vampire Cape Treat Bag

The bag itself stays plain kraft, but a black paper cape glued around the back transforms it into a mini Dracula complete with a red-lined collar.

Two tiny fangs cut from white card hang below the bag opening and a pair of red dot eyes finish the face. Make a batch for a class Halloween party: they are fast, graphic and need nothing more than card and glue.

Flatten after the party and save the capes separately for next year.

Pumpkin Paper Bag Luminary

Orange paint and a black jack-o-lantern face turn a standard bag into a glowing pumpkin lantern. The kraft paper takes orange paint readily and the colour is rich when lit from inside.

A scrunched square of green tissue paper stuffed into the top suggests the pumpkin stem. Line a windowsill with five or six of these and they look more like a styled vignette than a craft project.

Always use battery tea lights: this is a paper bag and an open flame is never appropriate.

Ghost Paper Bag Puppet

White paint, a black oval mouth and two large eyes are the whole recipe.

The charm of this puppet is in how expressive the face can be: a startled O mouth and wide round eyes reads as frightened ghost, while a grinning mouth and squinting eyes goes friendly.

Make a set of six with different expressions for a puppet-show kit that keeps children busy for the whole second half of a party. If you are hosting a preschool group, these Halloween crafts for toddlers have a few simpler puppets in the same spirit.

Crepe Paper Tassel Treat Bag

A kraft bag gets a full fringe of orange and black crepe paper tassels glued along the bottom edge, turning a plain favour bag into something that looks deliberately styled.

The tassels take three minutes per bag once you have the strip-cutting rhythm, and a table of thirty bags in alternating orange and black fringe looks genuinely dramatic. Tassels crush flat for storage and spring back to shape when the bag is filled.

Spider Paper Bag with Pipe Cleaner Legs

Eight pipe cleaner legs curl out from a round black paper bag, and two large white googly eyes stare from the top. The round shape comes from inflating the bag slightly and gathering the opening, which gives the spider a satisfying plump body.

These sit very happily in a cluster on a bookshelf or hanging from a doorway on black thread. They are fast enough to run as a drop-in station at a craft party: most children finish one in fifteen minutes.

Cauldron Treat Bag with Foam Sticker Brew

A round black paper bag becomes a bubbling cauldron when you add a ring of green foam bubble stickers along the top edge and a handle made from a black pipe cleaner threaded through two punched holes.

Children can fill these themselves at a treat station and carry them by the handle. After the party, remove the pipe cleaner handle, flatten the bag and stack it. The foam stickers stay put through an evening of handling.

Haunted House Silhouette Bag

A black paper silhouette of a haunted house with a crooked chimney, a jagged roofline and a yellow moon is glued to the front of a plain kraft bag.

It takes more cutting precision than the other bags in this list, but the result is a graphic, almost architectural treat bag that looks as if it came from a boutique stationery shop.

Make the silhouettes in a batch using a simple template traced once onto card. More Halloween paper cutting ideas are worth a look if you enjoy this style.

Skull and Crossbones Paper Bag

A classic skull face in white on a black or kraft bag, with two white crossbones below it, is one of those designs that takes less time than you expect and never looks cheap.

White paint on black bag reads as stark and graphic: bold enough to stack on a Halloween table without any further decoration around it.

This works equally well as a favour bag or as a wrapper for a small gift bottle of hand lotion or nail polish.

Bat Hanging Decoration from Paper Bags

Flatten a black paper bag, cut a bat wing profile through all layers and open it out to find a fully symmetrical bat ready to hang. No paint, no glue: just one cut and a length of string.

Make twenty in the time it takes to watch a half-hour programme, then hang them at varying heights from the ceiling for an instant Halloween canopy. After the party, fold them flat and store in a folder for next year with no damage.

Washi Tape Stripe Trick-or-Treat Bag

Four strips of Halloween washi tape applied vertically down a kraft bag create a candy-stripe effect in whatever combination you choose. Add a stamped or sticker label, fold the top, and the bag looks like something from a fancy gift shop.

This is the craft for the parent who wants a cohesive look across thirty favour bags without spending an afternoon cutting and gluing. Set up a tape station and children can do this themselves in under five minutes each.

Skeleton Paper Bag with Bone Stamps

A simple foam stamp shaped like a bone, dipped in white paint, makes a repeating skeleton pattern across the front of a black bag in less than two minutes.

The result reads as a printed pattern rather than a handmade craft, which is very much the point. Make the stamp from a thick foam sheet cut into a simple bone dumbbell shape: one stamp makes every bag in a batch of thirty.

This is also a good rainy afternoon project for children aged seven and up, because the printing action is satisfying and forgiving. Check out the full list of Halloween crafts for adults if you want more projects with this graphic sensibility.

Potion Bottle Label Bag

A small brown paper lunch bag becomes an apothecary potion bottle when you add a printed or handwritten label saying things like “Eye of Newt,” “Dragon Tears” or “Bat Wing Dust” and seal the top with a stopper of black tissue paper stuffed into the opening.

Line eight or ten of these on a shelf above a party table and they look like genuine witch’s pantry props. They also double as a favour bag when filled with sweets before sealing.

Scarecrow Brown Bag Puppet

A scarecrow is the slightly gentler Halloween character, and its patchy, stitched-together quality is easier to achieve on a paper bag than you might expect.

Raffia or torn strip of brown paper bag sticks out of the collar and cuffs as straw stuffing, paint patches and a pointy hat cut from black card complete the look.

This makes a good companion project to the Frankenstein puppet: set up both at a party table and children can do a miniature monster-versus-scarecrow puppet show.

For more craft table ideas for a group, the Halloween crafts for preschool article has a good section on setting up multiple simultaneous projects without chaos.

Frequently Asked Questions

What kind of paper bags work best for Halloween crafts?

Flat-bottomed kraft paper lunch bags are the most versatile. They stand upright, take paint and glue readily, and the flat base doubles as a puppet jaw. For treat bags you intend to carry, use a slightly larger kraft gift bag with twisted paper handles, which is sturdier than a lunch bag when loaded with candy.

How do you get paint to stick to kraft paper bags without bubbling?

Apply thin coats and let each one dry fully before adding the next. Thick coats are the main reason paint bubbles or peels on paper: the moisture has nowhere to go.

Acrylic paint dries faster than poster paint and bonds slightly better to the kraft surface, so it is the better choice for any bag that will be handled a lot.

Are paper bag crafts suitable for a whole class of children?

Yes, and they are one of the better craft formats for groups because the bags are uniform, the materials are cheap and the steps are short enough to complete in a forty-minute session. Prepare all adult-only steps (cutting, hot glue) ahead of time so children can focus on painting and decorating.

Can these bags actually hold trick-or-treat candy?

A standard kraft lunch bag holds roughly the same volume as a medium mixing bowl, which is enough for a practical haul of wrapped sweets.

If a child plans to carry the bag for more than one street, double-bag it by placing it inside a second plain bag: the decoration stays visible through the outer bag and the handles are more reliable.

How do you store decorated paper bags after Halloween?

Let any paint or glue dry completely, then flatten the bags and stack them inside a large zip-lock bag or a flat cardboard box. Crepe paper decorations benefit from a layer of tissue paper between bags to prevent colour transfer. Most bags last two or three seasons stored this way.

What can go wrong with the bag puppet method and how do you fix it?

The most common problem is painting the mouth in the wrong place so it does not move when the puppet is operated. The mouth must sit exactly on the fold line between the bag base flap and the bag body.

If the face dries in the wrong position, paint over it and start the face again: acrylic covers well with two coats.