72 This or That Pairs Built for an Instagram Story Poll

These this or that questions for Instagram are built exactly for the poll sticker: two options, one glance, instant engagement. Every pair below is genuinely balanced, which means your audience will actually split and your story analytics will spike. Six themed rounds let you post a whole series in one sitting without repeating yourself once.

This post contains affiliate links. If you buy through them, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

How to Play

Open Instagram Stories, pick a background colour or photo, drop in the Poll sticker, and type one option on each side. Work through the rounds in order so the energy builds: start with light everyday pairs and work toward the bigger personality questions at the end. Post two to four pairs per session so followers keep tapping back for more, or dump a full round of twelve in one sitting when you want maximum responses in one hour. The numbered lists below match the printable card sheets, so you can also print, cut and pass them around at a this or that game night before you post anything online.

Everyday Poll Pairs

Start with habits and routines: everyone has an opinion and nobody needs to think too hard before tapping.

1. Morning shower or evening shower
2. Alarm clock or no alarm
3. Coffee at home or coffee shop
4. Text first or wait to be texted
5. Noise while working or complete silence
6. Make your bed daily or skip it
7. Read physical books or e-reader
8. Grocery delivery or grocery store in person
9. Wash dishes immediately or leave until later
10. Reply to emails right away or batch them once a day
11. Phone face-up on the table or face-down
12. Early riser or night owl

Food Polls

Food pairs drive some of the loudest debates on Instagram because taste is personal and people defend their choices with real passion.

1. Sweet breakfast or savoury breakfast
2. Pizza with thin crust or deep dish
3. Tacos or burritos
4. Sushi or ramen
5. Ice cream or gelato
6. Cooking at home or eating out
7. Cake or pie
8. Hot sauce on everything or none at all
9. Pasta or rice as a base
10. Brunch or late-night snacks
11. Fresh fruit or dried fruit
12. Cheese board or charcuterie board

Style and Beauty Polls

Style questions reveal personality without getting personal, which makes them perfect for stories where the goal is connection without oversharing.

1. Minimalist wardrobe or maximalist closet
2. Sneakers or heels for a night out
3. Bold lip or bold eye
4. Gold jewellery or silver jewellery
5. Manicured nails or bare nails
6. Jeans or trousers as your daily uniform
7. Vintage finds or new-season pieces
8. Natural hair texture or styled every day
9. Fragrance every day or only for special occasions
10. Casual streetwear or tailored looks
11. Capsule wardrobe or seasonal shopping
12. Matching sets or mixed prints

Travel Polls

Travel pairs spark genuine debate because the gap between beach people and mountain people is real and enduring, as anyone who has tried to plan a group trip already knows. If you love building these kinds of engagement questions, the full bank at 120 Would You Rather questions has more pairs built for exactly this format.

1. Beach holiday or mountain retreat
2. Fly or road trip
3. All-inclusive resort or local guesthouse
4. Solo travel or group travel
5. City break or countryside escape
6. Hot destination or cold destination
7. Plan every detail or wing it
8. Carry-on only or checked luggage
9. Return to a favourite place or always go somewhere new
10. Tourist attractions or hidden local spots
11. Short frequent trips or one long trip per year
12. Travel for food or travel for scenery

Personality Polls

These pairs push a little deeper, asking followers to choose between two equally valid ways of moving through the world, which is where the comments really start.

1. Introvert recharge or extrovert recharge after a hard week
2. Logic first or gut feeling first
3. Planner or spontaneous
4. Conflict avoider or addresses it head-on
5. Optimist or realist
6. People person or prefers a tight circle
7. Creature of habit or always changing it up
8. Finishes one project before starting another or juggles many
9. Needs the last word or happy to let it go
10. Remembers faces or remembers names
11. Over-explains or under-explains
12. Thrives under pressure or works better with time to breathe

The Series Finale Poll

Save this round for last: these are the bigger, more revealing pairs that reward the followers who stayed with you through the whole series. They also work brilliantly as standalone posts when you want one question that carries the whole week. For more conversation-starting formats, the 150 Truth or Dare questions collection pairs well with this energy.

1. Fame or fortune
2. Be always honest or always kind when the two conflict
3. Live in one city forever or move every few years
4. Know your future or be surprised by it
5. One deep friendship or a wide social circle
6. Work you love at lower pay or work you tolerate at high pay
7. Be ten years older and wiser or ten years younger with what you know now
8. Perfect health or perfect career
9. Remembered for your achievements or remembered for how you made people feel
10. Change one past decision or keep everything as it happened
11. More time or more energy
12. Build something new or master something existing

How to Keep It Moving and When to Stop

Post one round at a time, not all six in one day. Spacing them across a week gives each set room to breathe and keeps your story views up rather than burning through your audience in an afternoon. Watch the poll results before you move to the next round: the pair that splits closest to 50/50 is the one worth reposting or turning into a follow-up question of your own design.

Stop when the results start to flatten. If a pair pulls 90 percent one way, the topic is too obvious for your specific audience and you can swap it for something tighter. The goal is the split, not the landslide. Keep a note of which pairs generated the most DMs or comment replies: those are the topics your audience wants to talk about, and they point directly at what your next content series should cover.

When you want the same energy in a room, print the card sheets on cardstock, run them through a laminator if you plan to reuse them, and deal them like a game. The pairs hold up just as well spoken aloud as they do on screen.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do I use these this or that questions for Instagram?

Open Instagram Stories, choose a background, tap the Poll sticker, and type one option on each side. Copy the pairs directly from any round below, post two to four per story session, and watch the split results come in.

How many polls should I post per day?

Two to four pairs per session keeps story views from dropping. Posting an entire round of twelve works well when you want a concentrated engagement burst in one hour, but spacing them across a week builds a returning audience.

Can I use these pairs at a party or game night instead of on Instagram?

Absolutely. Print the card sheets on cardstock, cut along the dashed lines, and deal them around the table. Each pair works just as well spoken aloud as it does typed into a poll sticker.

How do I print the card sheets?

Download the sheet, set your printer to A4 portrait at full scale, and print on 110lb cardstock for cards that hold up to handling. Run them through a home laminator if you want to reuse them, then punch a hole in the corner and thread a binder ring to keep sets together.

Which round gets the most engagement?

The Personality Polls and the Series Finale Poll tend to generate the most DMs and comments because the choices reveal something real about the person voting. Start with the lighter Everyday and Food rounds to warm up your audience before you get there.

Are these suitable for all adult audiences?

Yes. Every pair is PG-13 and brand-safe, so they work for personal accounts, brand accounts, and community pages without any editing.