72 Would You Rather Questions That Are Not the Same Twenty

Good would you rather questions are supposed to split the room, not produce a unanimous eye-roll because everyone has heard them already. These 72 pairs skip the desert-island scenarios, the superpower clichés and the “only eat one food forever” standards entirely. Six rounds, twelve pairs each, escalating from low-stakes to genuinely hard, with printable card sheets so the game runs itself.

This post contains affiliate links. If you buy through them, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

How to Play

One person reads a pair aloud. Everyone commits to an answer simultaneously, either by raising a hand, holding up a finger, or calling it out, so nobody hedges after hearing the room. The reader asks one or two follow-up questions (“why?”, “how long before you regret it?”), then moves to the next pair. No points, no winners, no timer unless the group gets stuck, in which case a 10-second countdown keeps things moving. The six rounds are designed to escalate, so play them in order the first time through.

Round One: Pairs You Have Not Heard

These twelve pairs look simple but produce longer arguments than they have any right to, because nobody has a pre-loaded answer ready.

1. Would you rather always know the exact time without checking, or always know the exact temperature wherever you are?
2. Would you rather have a photographic memory for faces but forget every name within an hour, or remember every name but be unable to picture any face?
3. Would you rather your phone never needs charging, or your car never needs fuel?
4. Would you rather be able to fast-forward through any boring wait but lose those minutes permanently, or live every moment in real time but have them all count?
5. Would you rather always find a parking spot immediately, or never wait in a queue again?
6. Would you rather know the exact word count of everything you have ever said, or the exact number of hours you have spent asleep?
7. Would you rather wake up five minutes before your alarm every single day, or sleep exactly as long as you planned every time?
8. Would you rather be able to read the mood of any room in under three seconds, or be completely immune to other people’s moods affecting yours?
9. Would you rather always have the right change, or always find a pen that works?
10. Would you rather your handwriting become perfect permanently, or your typing speed double permanently?
11. Would you rather be able to pause any video call without anyone noticing, or be able to send any text with a guaranteed read receipt within 60 seconds?
12. Would you rather always know when food has gone bad before you taste it, or always know which restaurant dish will disappoint before you order it?

Round Two: Small Everyday Trade-Offs

The low-stakes pairs are where everyone realises they care far more about trivial things than they expected, and the room gets loud fast.

1. Would you rather always have slightly cold coffee, or always have slightly flat fizzy drinks?
2. Would you rather your shower always runs five degrees cooler than ideal, or your bed always feels slightly too warm?
3. Would you rather always have to ask for the Wi-Fi password every time you visit a place, or always be the person who has to remember it for everyone else?
4. Would you rather every photo you take be slightly blurry, or every photo of you taken by others be perfectly sharp but unflattering?
5. Would you rather your headphones always tangle, or your charger cable always be one foot too short?
6. Would you rather always sit in a middle seat on any flight, or always get a window seat but with no window shade?
7. Would you rather your grocery order always have one substitution you did not approve, or always arrive ten minutes earlier than the delivery window?
8. Would you rather wear shoes that are half a size too big forever, or half a size too small forever?
9. Would you rather always have a slightly squeaky floor under your desk at work, or a slightly flickering light in your bathroom at home?
10. Would you rather always have to reboot your laptop to install an update at the worst possible moment, or always be the person who runs out of storage first?
11. Would you rather never be able to skip a song mid-play, or never be able to replay a song on the same day?
12. Would you rather always be five minutes early to everything, or always be exactly three minutes late to everything?

Round Three: Choices With No Good Option

This is the round where someone always says “neither” and gets shouted down, because the rules require a real pick.

1. Would you rather have to narrate everything you do out loud in real time, or have a running subtitled transcript of your thoughts visible to people within five feet of you?
2. Would you rather lose access to all streaming services permanently, or lose access to all social media permanently?
3. Would you rather give up the ability to listen to music, or give up the ability to watch any filmed content?
4. Would you rather know the one thing each of your close friends actually finds annoying about you, or never know and stay comfortable?
5. Would you rather have every conversation you have be recorded and stored somewhere you cannot delete, or have no record of any conversation you have ever had?
6. Would you rather be completely honest for one week with no filter, or say absolutely nothing for one week?
7. Would you rather lose your sense of smell or your sense of taste?
8. Would you rather have to read every terms-and-conditions document in full before using any app, or pay a monthly fee for every app you currently use for free?
9. Would you rather never be able to vent to anyone about a frustration, or be the person everyone vents to with no escape?
10. Would you rather always feel slightly underdressed wherever you go, or always feel slightly overdressed?
11. Would you rather find out a beloved memory from childhood did not happen the way you remember it, or never find out but always have a faint doubt?
12. Would you rather be the smartest person in every room but always underestimated, or average in every room but always taken seriously?

Round Four: Things You Would Actually Consider

These pairs feel almost reasonable, which is exactly what makes them harder to answer than the dramatic ones.

1. Would you rather work four 10-hour days or five 8-hour days, with the same pay and the same commute?
2. Would you rather have a housekeeper once a week or a personal chef three nights a week, if the cost were identical?
3. Would you rather live in a smaller home in a city you love, or a larger home somewhere you feel neutral about?
4. Would you rather have one month off work every year with full pay, or a 20 percent salary increase with the same holidays you have now?
5. Would you rather have a close friend who always tells you the truth even when it stings, or one who always makes you feel good even when you probably should not?
6. Would you rather spend a weekend completely alone recharging, or spend it with a large group of people you like?
7. Would you rather have a job you find genuinely interesting that pays adequately, or a job that bores you that pays extremely well?
8. Would you rather always know what your friends really think of your decisions, or keep the comfortable ambiguity?
9. Would you rather move to a new city where you know nobody and build from scratch, or stay exactly where you are for the next ten years?
10. Would you rather have a mentor who challenges you constantly but never praises you, or one who encourages you warmly but never pushes you?
11. Would you rather buy one quality item that lasts a decade, or replace a cheaper version every two years and always have something current?
12. Would you rather your daily commute be 45 minutes of walking, or 20 minutes of crowded public transport?

Round Five: The Surprising Round

These pairs come at the would you rather format from angles most groups have never tried, and the explanations are always more interesting than the actual answers.

1. Would you rather be the person who always sends the first text, or the one who always replies last?
2. Would you rather have the ability to hear every song for the first time again, or read every book you love for the first time again?
3. Would you rather know exactly how many true friends you have, given the precise number might be lower than you think, or keep estimating and stay comfortable?
4. Would you rather your most embarrassing moment be public knowledge to everyone you know but forgotten in five years, or private but something you replay privately for the rest of your life?
5. Would you rather always be the person who plans the thing, or always be the person who just shows up?
6. Would you rather live in a world where everyone is radically honest, or one where everyone is tactfully kind?
7. Would you rather have your life narrated by someone who clearly likes you, or directed by someone who wants it to be a great story even if that means hard chapters?
8. Would you rather be the most interesting person in a group of ordinary people, or an ordinary person in a group of fascinating ones?
9. Would you rather your younger self could see your life now, or your future self could see your life now?
10. Would you rather always be the person who remembers the important dates, or the person who always remembers the small details others share?
11. Would you rather have a morning routine that energises you every day but takes two hours, or a 15-minute routine that is fine but never exceptional?
12. Would you rather age visibly but feel young inside, or look exactly the same but feel every year physically?

Round Six: The Closing Round

The final twelve are the ones people keep talking about after the game ends, which is a sign of a good question format working exactly as it should.

1. Would you rather be known for one great thing you did once, or respected for consistent small efforts nobody notices?
2. Would you rather have the courage to say the hard thing at the right moment, or the wisdom to know when silence is better?
3. Would you rather look back on your life as one of comfort and stability, or one of risk and remarkable moments?
4. Would you rather be forgiven by someone you hurt, or be able to forgive someone who never apologised?
5. Would you rather know you made a real difference to ten people’s lives, or a small difference to a thousand people’s lives?
6. Would you rather be fully present in your life with all its ordinary moments, or always slightly restless and reaching for more?
7. Would you rather be remembered exactly as you are, flaws visible, or remembered as a polished version that is not quite you?
8. Would you rather have more time or more energy?
9. Would you rather have certainty about one big unresolved question in your life, or keep the possibility of any answer still being true?
10. Would you rather live a life that surprises you constantly, or one that unfolds almost exactly as you hoped?
11. Would you rather be loved by many people who know you lightly, or by a small number of people who know you completely?
12. Would you rather leave something behind that outlasts you, or live fully in the present and let it go?

How to Keep It Moving and When to Stop

The game stalls in two predictable places: someone who over-explains every answer before committing, and a pair so evenly matched that the debate never resolves. Both are easy to manage. Set a rule at the start that the answer comes before the reasoning, not after. If someone talks themselves into a different answer mid-sentence, the first answer stands.

The 10-second countdown works for stalling, but use it sparingly, twice per game at most, or it starts to feel like pressure rather than pace. For pairs that generate a genuine tie in the room, note them and revisit at the end, because the best conversations happen when the group returns to a pair with fresh context from the rounds in between.

Stop before the energy drops. Six rounds of twelve is 72 pairs total, and most groups hit their natural ceiling around round four or five. The closing round is designed to land on something reflective, so if the room is flagging, skip to it rather than grinding through. A game that ends 10 minutes early is always better than one that runs 10 minutes past its welcome.

Print the card sheets on cardstock, run them through a laminator if they will see more than one night of use, and punch a corner hole to keep each round on its own binder ring. The cards store flat and pull out quickly, which means the game starts in under a minute and no one has to read from a phone.

Frequently Asked Questions

How many players do you need for Would You Rather?

The game works from two players upward. Four to eight is the sweet spot because there are enough people to split the room and enough time for everyone to explain their reasoning without the round dragging.

Do you need to play all six rounds in one sitting?

No. Each round is self-contained. Play two rounds over dinner and save the rest for later, or use a single round as an icebreaker at the start of any gathering.

Can these questions be used with teenagers?

Most rounds are suitable for older teens, particularly rounds one and two. Rounds five and six touch on reflection and identity in ways that work well for 16 and up. For a younger crowd, the kids edition is a better fit.

How do I print the card sheets?

Print on 110lb cardstock for a sturdy feel. Cut along the dashed lines, laminate if the cards will see heavy use, and punch a hole in one corner to keep each round on its own binder ring.

What do you do if the group cannot decide between two options?

Call a 10-second countdown and make everyone commit. The first answer out of their mouth is the one that stands. Revisit genuinely tied pairs at the very end when the group has more context from the later rounds.

What is the difference between Would You Rather and This or That?

Would You Rather frames both options as hypothetical scenarios you step into, often with a consequence built in. This or That tends to be faster, preference-based and less scenario-driven. Both formats pair well together in the same evening.