2tablespoonslight brown sugarpacked, plus more to taste
1/4teaspoonfine sea salt
1/2teaspoonvanilla extract
2 to 3fresh orange wheelsfor garnish
1 1/2 to 2cupsspiced rum or bourbonfor the adult version (optional)
Instructions
Pour the apple cider into a 6-quart slow cooker (the white ceramic insert). Add the sliced orange, cinnamon sticks, whole cloves and allspice berries, pushing the spices and orange slices down so they are fully submerged in the cider.
Cover the slow cooker and cook on low for 3 to 4 hours, or on high for 1.5 to 2 hours, until the cider is steaming hot and the kitchen smells strongly of cinnamon and orange peel.
Lift out and discard the softened orange slices, cinnamon sticks, cloves and allspice berries with a slotted spoon, or strain the cider through a fine mesh sieve back into the insert, so the mulled cider runs clear and amber rather than cloudy.
Whisk the butterscotch sauce, brown sugar, salt and vanilla extract directly into the hot cider, stirring until the sauce fully dissolves and the cider turns a deep caramel color, about 1 minute.
Float the fresh orange wheels and a few new cinnamon sticks on top of the cider for serving, then switch the slow cooker to the warm setting so the drink stays hot without simmering again.
For the adult version, stir the spiced rum or bourbon directly into the slow cooker once the cider is on the warm setting rather than actively simmering, or keep the bottle beside the mugs and let each guest add about 1 1/2 ounces to their own.
Set a ladle, a stack of clear glass mugs, extra cinnamon sticks and orange wheels beside the slow cooker so guests can serve and garnish themselves through the evening.
Ladle about 1 cup of the warm cider into a clear glass mug, leaving a little room at the top for garnish.
Garnish with a fresh cinnamon stick and a half wheel of orange tucked on the rim, and serve immediately while it is still steaming.
Good to Know
Keep the slow cooker on low or warm once the cider is hot, never a hard simmer. Boiling it drives off both the fragrance and, in the spiked version, some of the alcohol.