3poundsfrozen cocktail meatballsabout 60, fully cooked, beef or a beef and pork blend
1jar32 ounces grape jelly
2bottles12 ounces each chili sauce (24 ounces total), such as Heinz
Instructions
In a large white ceramic mixing bowl, whisk together the 32-ounce jar of grape jelly and both 12-ounce bottles of chili sauce for about a minute. The jelly will look lumpy and refuse to blend smoothly at first: that is normal, it finishes melting once it hits the heat of the slow cooker.
Tip the 3 pounds of frozen cocktail meatballs straight from the bag into a 6-quart slow cooker, no need to thaw first. A 6-quart crock holds the full 3 pounds, around 60 meatballs, with room to spare; in a 4-quart crock, hold back to about 2 pounds, roughly 40 meatballs, so the sauce has space to bubble without spilling over the rim.
Pour the grape jelly and chili sauce mixture over the meatballs and stir with a long wooden spoon, turning the meatballs from the bottom up until every one wears an even, glossy coat. Scrape along the base of the crock as you go so no pocket of straight jelly sits there and scorches.
Cover with the lid and cook on low for 4 hours. At the two hour mark, lift the lid and stir once, folding the sauce that has settled at the bottom back up and over the meatballs so the jelly melts evenly rather than pooling.
Remove the lid for the final 30 minutes of cooking and let the sauce simmer uncovered. Watch it turn from thin and cloudy to a deep, glossy red: this is the sauce reducing to a consistency that clings to a spoon rather than running off it.
Check doneness with an instant read thermometer in the center of a meatball or two: it should read at least 165°F, which fully cooked frozen meatballs reach quickly once the surrounding sauce is hot.
Stir once more, then switch the slow cooker to the warm setting. Serve straight from the crock with toothpicks alongside, giving the sauce an occasional stir through the party so it stays glossy instead of developing a skin.
Good to Know
Whisk the jelly into the chili sauce before it ever meets the meatballs; a jelly brick left to melt on its own scorches on the bottom of the crock instead of blending into the sauce.