Press the sausage into 4 patties about 1/4 inch thick and slightly wider than the English muffins, since they shrink as they cook.
Heat a skillet over medium heat and cook the patties for 4 minutes per side until browned outside and no longer pink in the center.
Season each patty with a pinch of pepper as it cooks.
Lay a slice of cheddar over each patty for the last minute of cooking so it melts fully.
While the sausage finishes, butter the cut sides of the English muffins and toast them split side down in a separate dry skillet for 2 minutes until deep gold.
Set a sausage patty with melted cheddar on the bottom half of each muffin.
Close with the top muffin half, pressing gently to settle the patty.
Slice in half if serving right away to show the sausage and cheddar layer, or wrap whole for freezing.
Good to Know
Double the batch on a Sunday: wrap each sandwich individually and freeze up to two months, then reheat from frozen at 350°F for about 20 minutes.