Go Back
Classic Grinch Punch With Lime Sherbet

Classic Grinch Punch With Lime Sherbet

Prep Time 15 minutes
Total Time 4 hours 15 minutes
Makes 16 servings

Ingredients

  • 2 quarts lime sherbet softened slightly
  • 64 ounces green Hawaiian Punch or green berry fruit punch chilled
  • 32 ounces pineapple juice chilled
  • 1 liter lemon-lime soda chilled
  • red sanding sugar for the rims
  • extra pineapple juice for dipping the rims
  • 16 candy hearts or red cinnamon candies for garnish

Instructions

  • Chill the fruit punch, pineapple juice and soda for at least 4 hours, or overnight: cold liquids keep the sherbet from melting into soup the second it hits the bowl.
  • Pour a little pineapple juice into a shallow saucer and the red sanding sugar into a second saucer. Dip the rim of each punch cup first in the juice, then in the sugar, turning to coat evenly, and set the cups upright to dry.
  • Scoop the lime sherbet into the bottom of a large 2 to 3 quart punch bowl, spacing the scoops so none of them touch.
  • Pour the chilled green fruit punch slowly over the sherbet, aiming at the side of the bowl rather than straight down, so it builds a cloudy green pool instead of mashing the scoops flat.
  • Pour in the pineapple juice the same way and give the bowl one gentle stir, just enough to swirl the colors together; the sherbet should still float in visible islands.
  • Add the lemon-lime soda last, pouring around the edge so the fizz survives. The surface will foam up pale green and settle within a minute, which is how you know it is ready.
  • Ladle the punch into the sugar-rimmed cups, making sure each cup gets a piece of sherbet, and drop one candy heart onto the foam of each.
  • Serve at once. The sherbet keeps the punch cold for about an hour in the bowl; after that, float a few fresh scoops on top to revive it.

Good to Know

Mix the fruit punch and pineapple juice up to 2 days ahead and refrigerate; add the soda and sherbet only right before guests arrive.