72 Would You Rather Questions for Brothers and Sisters

Would you rather questions for siblings are the fastest way to turn a family dinner, road trip or reunion into the kind of conversation people quote for years. These 72 prompts are organised into six escalating rounds, each one anchored in the shared childhood that only brothers and sisters actually lived through. No sharp edges, no real arguments, just the satisfying chaos of finding out your sibling would absolutely choose the wrong answer.

This post contains affiliate links. If you buy through them, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

How to Play

Read a question aloud and give everyone three seconds to pick a side before the talking starts. Play in rounds, working through one full list before moving to the next. With a big family, split into two teams and award a point whenever the majority picks the same answer. With just two siblings, every answer is a debate. The printable cards let you cut, shuffle and draw blind so nobody skips the questions they are afraid of. Print them on cardstock for durability, and run them through a laminator or slip them onto a binder ring so the deck survives the reunion.

Round One: Childhood Memories

Start where every sibling story starts, back in the house you grew up in, and see whose version of events holds up.

1. Would you rather relive your best birthday party as a kid OR your most legendary family game night?
2. Would you rather go back and spend one full Saturday in your childhood bedroom OR one full day in your childhood backyard?
3. Would you rather re-read every book from your childhood bookshelf OR rewatch every movie you wore out on repeat?
4. Would you rather eat your all-time favourite childhood meal once a week forever OR eat it just once more, exactly as it tasted then?
5. Would you rather get your childhood allowance back but have to follow every house rule again OR keep your adult freedom with no extra money?
6. Would you rather wake up tomorrow in your childhood home with your current mind OR in your current home but with your most carefree childhood feeling restored?
7. Would you rather have every family photo from your childhood printed and framed OR have every home video digitised and saved forever?
8. Would you rather go back and ace the school test you bombed most memorably OR nail the performance, game or recital you practised hardest for?
9. Would you rather have your childhood best friend move back next door OR have your favourite teacher from school become your professional mentor now?
10. Would you rather keep every toy you owned as a kid OR keep every piece of clothing you actually loved back then?
11. Would you rather relive the last day of school before summer every year OR relive the first morning of a school holiday every year?
12. Would you rather remember every song you knew by heart as a child OR remember every joke you thought was hilarious at age eight?

Round Two: Who Got Away With What

Every family has a statute of limitations, and this round is it. Both options should feel equally tempting and equally incriminating.

1. Would you rather confess the thing you got away with as a kid OR find out the thing your sibling got away with that you never knew about?
2. Would you rather have been caught for your worst rule-break but only been grounded for a day OR never been caught but always felt guilty about it?
3. Would you rather admit you once blamed your sibling for something you did OR hear your sibling admit they once blamed you for something they did?
4. Would you rather have been the sibling who always played by the rules OR the one who always found the loophole?
5. Would you rather confess which snack you secretly ate from the kitchen at night OR find out which snack your sibling was stealing the whole time?
6. Would you rather admit the most elaborate excuse you ever made up for missing a chore OR hear your sibling’s most creative excuse in full detail?
7. Would you rather have been grounded once for a whole month and then totally forgiven OR been in mild ongoing trouble for an entire school year?
8. Would you rather admit you used your sibling’s belongings without asking OR admit you read their diary, journal or private messages even once?
9. Would you rather find out which of your childhood tall tales your parents always knew was a lie OR find out which ones they actually believed?
10. Would you rather have been the kid who tattled once and regrets it OR the kid who stayed quiet once and regrets that instead?
11. Would you rather confess the most dramatic fake illness you ever used to skip something OR the most outrageous reason you gave for being late?
12. Would you rather admit the thing you borrowed from a sibling and never returned OR admit the thing you broke and quietly hid or replaced?

Round Three: Swapping Lives

This is the round where siblings discover whether they actually wanted each other’s lives all along.

1. Would you rather have grown up as the oldest sibling in your family OR the youngest?
2. Would you rather swap birth order with one sibling for one full year of your childhood OR keep your own birth order but trade bedrooms permanently?
3. Would you rather have had your sibling’s closest childhood friend group OR your sibling’s favourite hobby at its peak?
4. Would you rather swap your childhood report card with your sibling’s best one OR swap your most impressive personal achievement from that era?
5. Would you rather have grown up sharing a bedroom with your sibling OR grown up with your sibling in the room next door but always borrowing your things?
6. Would you rather live one week of your sibling’s current daily routine OR have your sibling live one week of yours?
7. Would you rather swap one skill your sibling has that you genuinely envy OR swap one personality trait they have that makes life easier for them?
8. Would you rather have had your sibling’s after-school activities growing up OR their weekend schedule?
9. Would you rather switch places for one family holiday when you were kids OR switch places for one major family milestone as adults?
10. Would you rather take on your sibling’s current job for one month OR have them take on yours?
11. Would you rather grow up with your sibling’s taste in music OR their taste in food?
12. Would you rather swap your sibling’s most useful practical skill OR their most entertaining party trick?

Round Four: Family Holidays

Shared holidays are the richest material any sibling team owns, and this round mines every last detail of them.

1. Would you rather relive your best family holiday exactly as it happened OR redesign it with unlimited budget but the same people?
2. Would you rather go on a road trip for two weeks with your whole family OR fly somewhere for five days with just one sibling?
3. Would you rather have the family holiday tradition of a big trip every other year OR a smaller but guaranteed trip every single year?
4. Would you rather share a hotel room with your sibling for a week OR share a tent with them for four nights?
5. Would you rather relive the most chaotic holiday journey your family ever had OR the most boring one where absolutely nothing happened?
6. Would you rather have had a family holiday caravan every summer OR a beach rental every summer?
7. Would you rather go back and do the holiday activity your parents loved that you resisted at the time OR finally admit it was actually fun?
8. Would you rather be in charge of choosing every family holiday destination for the next five years OR never have to plan a single trip but go wherever the family decides?
9. Would you rather relive the holiday where the weather ruined everything OR the one where a small mishap turned into the best story?
10. Would you rather have every family holiday photo restored and organised into one perfect album OR have a professional short film made from all the old video clips?
11. Would you rather bring one friend on every future family trip OR have your family always do holidays with one other whole family?
12. Would you rather repeat the longest family road trip you ever survived OR repeat the most eventful flight your family ever took?

Round Five: Honest Preferences

No backstory needed here: these are the clean, direct preference questions that reveal more than people expect.

1. Would you rather always be the one who remembers every family birthday OR always be the one who throws the best party for them?
2. Would you rather your sibling always be honest with you even when it stings OR always be kind to you even if it means a small white lie?
3. Would you rather have a sibling who texts you every single day OR one who calls once a month for a genuinely long conversation?
4. Would you rather be the sibling everyone calls first in a crisis OR the sibling everyone calls first with good news?
5. Would you rather have a sibling who lives five minutes away OR a sibling who lives far but visits for one full week every year?
6. Would you rather always be the one who gives the most thoughtful gift OR always be the one who gives the most useful one?
7. Would you rather your sibling remember one important thing you told them years ago OR immediately forget one embarrassing thing you said last week?
8. Would you rather be the sibling known for giving the best advice OR the one known for always showing up when needed?
9. Would you rather have a sibling who is endlessly funny OR endlessly reliable?
10. Would you rather share every piece of good news with your sibling first OR know your sibling shares every piece of good news with you first?
11. Would you rather your sibling always have time for you OR always have exactly the right words when you need them?
12. Would you rather be the sibling who makes everyone laugh at every family gathering OR the one who makes everyone feel genuinely seen?

Round Six: The Round That Ends Well

Save this one for last. These questions are warm, a little reflective and designed to leave the room feeling good rather than competitive.

1. Would you rather have a highlight reel of every funny moment you and your sibling have shared OR a highlight reel of every time one of you helped the other through something hard?
2. Would you rather your sibling know exactly how much they mean to you without you having to say it OR get to say it in full and know they fully heard it?
3. Would you rather pass down one family story to the next generation together OR create one brand-new tradition that starts with just the two of you?
4. Would you rather have one perfect day with your whole family exactly as it is right now OR one perfect day with your family as it was at your favourite age growing up?
5. Would you rather your sibling remember you at your funniest OR at your most genuinely kind?
6. Would you rather receive a handwritten letter from your sibling telling you what they admire about you OR sit with them for an evening where you just talk with nowhere to be?
7. Would you rather know your sibling is always in your corner even when you are wrong OR know they will always tell you the truth even when it is hard to hear?
8. Would you rather grow old living near your sibling OR grow old knowing you can call them any hour of any day?
9. Would you rather be remembered by your family as the funniest one OR the most dependable one?
10. Would you rather leave your siblings one object that perfectly sums up your relationship OR one letter that says everything you have never quite found the moment to say?
11. Would you rather spend one whole unplanned day with all your siblings doing whatever comes naturally OR plan one perfect day together with everyone’s favourite things included?
12. Would you rather know for certain that your sibling is proud of who you have become OR know for certain that they genuinely enjoy spending time with you?

How to Keep It Moving and When to Stop

Set a two-minute timer per question if the group gets stuck debating rather than deciding. The point is the vote, not the verdict. If someone wants to skip a question, let them draw the next card without comment. No question is worth an awkward silence that lingers past the game.

Watch the room after Round Four. Some groups will want to power through all six rounds in one sitting. Others will peak around Round Three and coast, and that is a sign to wrap up, declare whoever had the most majority votes the winner, and move on to something easier. A great game knows when to end.

If you want to keep the energy up between rounds, try a quick wider would you rather prompt list as a palate cleanser, or pull a few rounds from a truth or dare set to change the pace entirely. The printable cards make it easy to mix decks without losing track of which round you are in, since every sheet carries the round name right at the top.

The single rule that keeps every sibling game from going sideways: if an answer genuinely bothers someone, move on without a scene. The goal is a good memory, not a resolved verdict on who was the favourite child.

Frequently Asked Questions

How many players do you need for would you rather questions for siblings?

The game works with just two siblings and scales up to a full family table of any size. With larger groups, split into teams and score majority votes to keep everyone engaged.

Are these questions appropriate for all ages?

Yes. Every prompt is PG and family-safe, written so that younger siblings and parents in the room can all participate without anyone feeling left out or uncomfortable.

How do you print the card sheets?

Download the sheet, print at home on standard letter or A4 cardstock, and cut along the printed lines. Run each sheet through a laminator for durability, or punch a hole in the corner of each card and thread them onto a binder ring.

Can you play all six rounds in one sitting?

Most groups move through two or three rounds comfortably in under an hour. Six rounds is the full experience for a longer gathering. Watch the energy around Round Four and wrap up whenever the room starts to wind down naturally.

What is the best way to keep the game fair and fun?

Give everyone a fixed few seconds to commit to an answer before discussion opens. Allow anyone to pass on a single question per round without explanation. The rule that keeps things light: no answer is wrong, and no round is a trial.

Do you need to play the rounds in order?

The rounds are designed to escalate gently from nostalgic to reflective, so playing in order gives the best experience. For a shorter session, Rounds One, Five and Six make a satisfying standalone set.